|
|
Monthly Roundup – September 2024
|
|
|
|
Note: anchor links are not supported by all email clients which might lead to limited functionality.
|
|
|
|
Europe: Georgeson’s 2024 European AGM Season Review
Georgeson’s 2024 European AGM Season Review provides a comprehensive analysis of the trends observed at AGMs across eight of Europe's key markets. This report offers valuable insights into investor voting behaviours, corporate governance developments, and the influence of proxy advisors.
|
|
|
|
|
UK: Computershare and Georgeson’s 2024 UK AGM Intelligence Report
Computershare and Georgeson’s 2024 AGM Intelligence Report explores the emerging meeting and governance trends in the UK. This year's report features a new layout delving into essential insights from the evolving corporate governance landscape.
|
|
|
|
|
Europe: Georgeson’s Domenic Brancati is quoted in Board Agenda’s article titled “European AGM shareholder opposition down on last year”
Domenic Brancati, global COO of Georgeson, says the trend appears to replicate events in the US and suggests that companies have prioritised shareholder engagement over the past year.
However, while overall opposition is down, the figures reveal that European concern with executive pay remains higher than any other issue. “The data also shows that, similar to last year, shareholders in European companies continue to oppose remuneration-related resolutions at higher rates than other resolution types,” Brancati says.
|
|
|
|
|
Australia: Georgeson’s Paul Murphy is quoted in FS Sustainability’s article titled “Exec pay lands listed firms in hot water”
"Shareholder strikes against companies' executive remuneration reports and lower average support for director nominees highlight a growing focus on board member accountability at AGMs, which we also expect to continue in the upcoming Australian AGM season," said Paul Murphy, head of ESG Asia Pacific at Georgeson.
|
|
|
|
|
US: Georgeson’s Kilian Moote is quoted in Agenda’s article titled “Boards Explore Risks from Chevron Doctrine’s Overruling”
“Although the decision is a topic boards should explore, the need to do so may not be pressing, according to Kilian Moote, U.S. head of the ESG advisory practice at Georgeson and one of the speakers on Agenda's webcast. If they decide to discuss the risks and opportunities, directors should ensure that they are engaging with appropriate stakeholders as they navigate the potential environment of regulatory uncertainty, he said.”
|
|
|
|
|
US: Georgeson’s US Season Review data is quoted in the Wall Street Journal’s opinion piece titled “Fight Wokeness With Small Government”
“Companies are also getting pushback from shareholders on their environmental, social and governance policies. A report from shareholder consulting firm Georgeson found that investors submitted more anti-ESG proposals at annual shareholder meetings between July 2023 and May 2024 than in any previous year.”
|
|
|
|
|
Spain: Georgeson’s data is quoted in Cinco Días’ article titled “Large listed companies opt for the permanent shareholders' meeting model” (“Las grandes cotizadas apuestan por el modelo de junta permanente de accionistas”)
“Georgeson's document shows that remuneration reports were the resolutions with the highest proportion of negative recommendations by proxy advisors this year. Among Ibex companies, only one resolution was rejected: at Grifols, when the board of directors sought authorisation to reduce the notice period for convening Extraordinary General Meetings to 15 days.”
|
|
|
|
|
Australia: Georgeson’s data is quoted in the Australian Financial Review’s article titled “Big AGM voter Vanguard ready to wield its proxies to challenge boards”
“Last year was a bit of a bloodbath for companies as far as these things go. Remuneration report strikes (a 25 per cent-plus vote in protest) nearly doubled to 41 across the S&P/ASX 300, according to proxy advisory firm Georgeson.”
|
|
|
|
|
Europe: Georgeson hosted a webinar and investor panel to present the findings of the 2024 European AGM Season Review
|
|
|
|
Georgeson’s Daniele Vitale presented the findings of the 2024 European AGM Season Review and moderated a panel with UBS’s Matteo Passero, Amundi’s Edouard Dubois, and Schroders’ Pippa O’Riley. If you registered for the event but were not able to attend, the video recording is accessible at the link below. If you were unable to register for the webinar but would still like to watch the recording, please email Daniele Vitale.
|
|
|
|
|
Spain: Georgeson will be presenting its joint study with Cuatrecasas on 16 October in Barcelona at an event titled “How to prepare for the 2025 Proxy Season” (“Recursos Eventos Cómo preparar la Temporada de Juntas 2025”)
|
|
|
|
On 16 October, Georgeson and Cuatrecasas will be presenting a new edition of our annual study which analyses the behaviour of investors during the last proxy season and identifies the main challenges for the 2025 proxy season in order to help listed companies be prepared for their next ordinary meeting. The event will take place in Barcelona. The same event was held in Madrid in September.
|
|
|
|
|
France: Georgeson’s Matthieu Simon-Blavier spoke at an Uptevia webinar titled “Forum Émetteurs”
|
|
|
|
The webinar included discussions on the following:
- A look back at the 2024 AGM season
- Changes in documentation and regulation in 2025
- Highlighting the voting process: from shareholder dialogue, to investor voting expectations, to implementation in the tool
|
|
|
|
|
Greece: Georgeson’s Alberto D’Aroma presented at the Greek Real Estate Investment Forum 2024
|
|
|
|
The hybrid conference, which took place on 24 September in Athens, focused on the challenges and development prospects for professional property management, and on the advantages and benefits of the Greek real estate market. Georgeson’s Alberto D’Aroma joined the second panel as a speaker, talking about new sustainability factors impacting real estate investment decisions, the relevance of the taxonomy grid and ESG KPIs in the investment decision process.
|
|
|
|
|
UK: Nominations are now open for the Non-Executive Awards which Georgeson is sponsoring
|
|
|
|
The Non-Executive Director Awards were established in 2006, by Peel Hunt, to recognise the achievements of Non-Executive Directors who contribute daily to the success and growth of businesses and Not-for-Profit organisations across the UK. The Nominations Opening was covered by the Times.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- The Financial Times reports Vanguard backed no environmental or social measures in 2024 proxy season: “Support on votes has been dwindling among big money managers after reaching record levels just a few years ago”.
- The Financial Times reports The way forward for ESG: “Actual owners of shares should have more say than their hired fund managers”. Alex Edmans’ response to the article can be read here.
- The Institutional Investors Group on Climate Change reports Proxy advisors are essential for investor engagement - key topics to consider: “Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis have released their annual benchmark policy surveys. Responses to these surveys will feed into the policies that inform their voting recommendations. They give investors the opportunity to engage with ISS and Glass Lewis to ensure that the views of the investment community are considered, and that climate is fully integrated into their analysis.”
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- BVI published its Analysis Guidelines for Shareholder Meetings 2025: “The BVI’s Analysis Guidelines for Annual General Meetings 2025 (“ALHV 2025” – Annex) support investment management companies in preparing for votes at Annual General Meetings and promote dialogue between the German fund industry and companies. They go beyond both the statutory minimum standards and the recommendations of the German Corporate Governance Code (GCGC).”
|
|
- Vincent Kaufmann, the CEO of the Ethos Foundation, writes about Sustainability reporting: first impressions of the Swiss legislation: “During the 2024 AGM season, the largest listed companies in Switzerland – with at least 500 employees and annual sales of more than CHF 40 million – had to prepare a sustainability report and submit it for shareholder approval.”
|
|
- The Financial Times reports Italy to review corporate governance rules after shareholder pressure: “Senior government official says new law is ‘an opportunity we cannot miss’ to fix issues in capital markets bill”. Read the International Corporate Governance Network’s letter in response to these developments here.
- The Financial Times reports Global investors warn Italy over capital markets reforms: “Fund managers urge ‘rethink’ of controversial corporate governance rules”.
- La Repubblica reports Capitali law, a quake for Generali, Mediobanca and TIM (“Legge Capitali, un terremoto per Generali, Mediobanca e Tim”): “It was clear that it would generate a lot of confusion in listed companies governance and that rules were byzantine. But now Massimo Belcredi and Stefano Bozzi, both Professors of corporate finance at the Cattolica University, put themselves to work to assess what would have been the effect of the Capitali Law on the results of AGMs with the presence of board slates over the last four years (2021-2024).”
- Il Sole24Ore reports M&A, sustainability is a decisive criterion for investors (“M&A, la sostenibilità criterio decisivo per gli investitori”): “With the entry into force of the European directive CSDDD, the need to respect ESG factors is extended to supply chains. Sustainability is becoming an increasingly decisive factor to guide M&A operations in Europe. With the entry into force, last July, of the European directive CSDDD (Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive), which requires companies with more than one thousand employees to assess all the supply chain with regard to ESG aspects, the consideration of these aspects within the investment evaluation and selection framework has become pivotal for groups or funds testing the M&A market.”
|
|
- El País reports The Hungarian group Ganz-MaVag withdraws the offer to buy Talgo after the Government's veto (“El grupo húngaro Ganz-MaVag retira la oferta de compra por Talgo tras el veto del Gobierno”): “The board of directors of the Hungarian group Ganz-MaVag has decided to withdraw its takeover bid for the Spanish train manufacturer Talgo, after the veto of the Spanish government at the end of August, and after the European Commission had endorsed the government's decision.”
- Expansión reports The ECB gives the green light to BBVA's takeover bid for Sabadell (“El BCE da luz verde a la opa de BBVA sobre Sabadell”): “The European Central Bank (BCE) has authorized BBVA's takeover bid for Sabadell, as reported by the entity in relevant information sent to the CNMV. Technically it is not an approval, but a report of non-opposition. This decision by the European regulator is "a new very important milestone that also underlines the solidity and solvency of this project", said Carlos Torres.”
- El Economista reports The Government authorises BlackRock's entry into Naturgy but vetoes a takeover bid for exclusion (“El Gobierno autoriza la entrada de BlackRock en Naturgy pero veta una OPA de exclusion”): “The Council of Ministers has authorised BlackRock's request to acquire the fund Global Infrastructure Partners (GIP). This purchase operation will involve a change in Naturgy’s shareholders. The Ministry of Economy did not want to comment on the conditions imposed to Larry Fink's fund, but market sources indicate that maintaining the headquarters in Spain and the rejection to carry out an exclusion takeover bid are among them.”
- Forbes España reports Banco Santander, CIE Automotive and Telefónica, companies with the best quality in their reports (“Banco Santander, CIE Automotive y Telefónica, empresas con mejor calidad en sus informes a accionistas”): “Banco Santander, CIE Automotive and Telefónica are the companies that offer their shareholders the highest quality reports, according to a study by the communication agency Deva, which analyses the quality of the reports that Spanish listed companies provide to their shareholders and stakeholders on the occasion of the ordinary annual general meeting. The ranking by industry is led by the Oil and Energy.”
|
|
|
|
|
|
North American developments
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- Bloomberg reports China to Compel New Sectors to Join Carbon Market by End-2025: “China plans to impose carbon-trading compliance obligations on steel, aluminum, and cement producers next year as the country extends its carbon market to compel more polluting sectors to slash emissions. About 1,500 companies in those industries will be subject to market-based carbon costs from next year if their emissions overshoot government-set targets, according to a consultation paper issued by the Ministry of Ecology and Environment.”
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
- The Australian Financial Review reports Wall Street’s ESG backlash does little to dent Australia’s enthusiasm: “Australia’s largest companies have defied investor pressure to walk back environmental, social and governance commitments, and are increasingly talking about these issues on earnings calls in contrast with their peers in the United States. A Jarden analysis of topics flagged in earnings calls over the ASX earnings season in August showed a 13 per cent increase in mentions over the past year, including a 3 per cent increase in talk about renewables, 13 per cent for the energy transition and 24 per cent for climate exposure.“
- The Age reports HESTA pressures Australia’s largest companies to adopt gender targets across entire organisation: “Industry super fund HESTA will leverage its voting power to force some of Australia’s largest publicly listed companies to set gender targets across the entire organisation – not just at the board and executive level – to address the gender pay gap. The $87 billion fund wants them to commit to ensuring 40 per cent of its staff are women, after the Workplace Gender Equality Agency (WEGA) released data this year showing the gender pay gap was more than 20 per cent in the private sector."
- The Tasmanian Times reports SIX Slaps Supermarket Shareholders Over Salmon: “Australian supermarket giant Woolworths will be the first company in the world to face a shareholder resolution aiming to prevent an extinction event. At the Woolworths AGM on 31 October, shareholders will be asked to vote on whether Woolworths should stop sourcing farmed salmon from Macquarie Harbour, Tasmania, and give the endangered Maugean skate its ‘best chance at survival’. Salmon produced in Macquarie Harbour threatens the existence of the skate, whose population numbers have plummeted to an estimated 40-120 adults.”
- Climateworks reports Fortescue has put its ambitious green hydrogen target on hold – but Australia should keep powering ahead: “Fortescue Executive Chairman and Founder Andrew Forrest has been quick to reject claims the company is walking back from its green hydrogen dreams more broadly, telling Nine Radio in Perth on Thursday: ‘We just have to work out now how to produce it cheaply enough.’ Developing renewable hydrogen at scale – like any industry – will require both national and global action to build demand, by supporting new technologies and lowering the risk of investing in early projects. Over time, this will bring prices down.”
|
|
|
|
|
|
Head of ESG, UK and Europe
|
|
|
|
|
|